Postgrad LIVE! Study Fairs

Birmingham | Edinburgh | Liverpool | Sheffield | Southampton | Bristol

University of Bristol Featured PhD Programmes
University of Oxford Featured PhD Programmes
University of Edinburgh Featured PhD Programmes
Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council Featured PhD Programmes
Birkbeck, University of London Featured PhD Programmes

PhD Discussion Forum

The following thread is brought to you by our sister Web site PostgraduateForum.com. If you wish to reply or post your own thread, you will be redirected to this site.

This Category:   PostgraduateForum.com > PhD Advice / Support


Message

When would you know that a material is worthy to be published?


User: tt_dan - 08 July 2012 14:28


Right, so I'm new to the academic publishing world, when or how could we tell that our material is worthy of being published, or should be published? My co-supervisor said that one could even publish a 'concept paper' (if I'm not mistaken) just to let the world know what we are doing at the moment.

Any input is appreciated.

User: keenbean - 08 July 2012 20:59

Hi Tt_Dan! To be honest, the best way to know is to ask for an opinion from someone who is used to publishing work and knows whereabouts the standard needs to be, or just submit it to a journal and find out! If you think you have something original that's of interest to others in the field, it's worth a shot, and even if it gets rejected you should get some constructive feedback that would enable you to work further on it. There isn't really anything to lose by trying. Are you doing a PhD? What field are you in? I finished my PhD in Clinical Psychology last year and so far have 7 publications out of it- two systematic reviews, four results papers, and a conceptual paper. Where I studied for my PhD it was pretty normal to get stuff published, but it's more common in some fields than others. But if you want to carry on in academia afterwards then it's great to publish- it will go a long way to getting you a post-doc (again, depending on what field you're in!). Good luck! KB

User: Crions - 09 September 2018 16:59

Hello! To be honest, i am no sure that i have an experience big enough to give you an advise, that's why i'd better listen to other information here :)

User: Tudor_Queen - 09 September 2018 22:10

Best things to do are:
- compare it to other already published papers
- ask supervisors if they think it is ready
- if yes to (preferably both) the above, submit and see (aim to where you / your supervisors think it would fit perfectly, or else aim higher and get amazing feedback!)

I'd never try any online service unless I'd been told that my writing wasn't good enough (presumably that's what they're for?) or something similar to warrant the need to do that.

Good luck!

User: pm133 - 10 September 2018 20:02

TQ, this thread is 6 years old.
fenlon_lisa has re-opened it solely to sell their online editing services.
It's tedious that this is happening again on this site.

User: Tudor_Queen - 10 September 2018 20:39

Oh lol! I didn't notice the date of the original poster, only the follow up comment! Arghh... thanks for the heads up.





FindAPhD. Copyright 2005-2018
All rights reserved.