PhD Discussion Forum

The following thread is brought to you by our sister Web site PostgraduateForum.com. If you wish to reply or post your own thread, you will be redirected to this site.

Search Forum Post new topic

Post reply on Postgrad Forum | Sort latest to earliest | Back to topics

Author	Message
PhDinUK2022 [Registered User] 01 May 2022 07:34	Missed Deadline for Monthly Review at University of Birmingham User: PhDinUK2022 - 01 May 2022 07:34 Hi Everyone, I am having a little bit of a panic moment here. I am currently doing a PhD at the University of Birmingham, and I was unable to complete the GRS2 form for April last night and today it will not allow me to complete it. The GRS2 form is UoB's monthly review form to keep track of the PGR and the Supervisor's interaction and the PGR's progress. All I needed to do was the last step of accepting the supervisor's comment and I missed the deadline. I am worried about how this will affect my PhD. I have asked them if I can still amend it but if I can not does anyone know what the repercussions are? Any help would be appreciated.
abababa [Registered User] 06 May 2022 02:12	User: abababa - 06 May 2022 02:12 Hi, It's interesting they have a formal monthly review system - this is unusual. Normally, PhD progress is evaluated internally on an annual basis. A PhD is - to use the cliche - a PhD. It doesn't have grading; it doesn't track what happened along the way. It just is. As a consequence, the only way internal reviews will impact it, is if the outcome is the University refuses to allow you to continue to study. It is not in the University's best interests to do this as they lose the fees and prospect of a completion; it's generally done on an ethical basis that there is no realistic prospect of you completing, and therefore it's wrong to allow you to continue. I would think you can rest easy that unless your research itself is way off-track (as judged by your supervisory team), failing to file paperwork will not be a deal-breaker. Many students also worry about training-credit style systems, or other hurdles the Uni implements. Ultimately if you're doing good research and can complete, they will let you do so. It is still preferable to file paperwork where you can, as admin-types will get pent up about it, but I've never seen someone fail a PhD on the basis of a missed monthly meeting or training exercise.

Author

Message

PhDinUK2022

[Registered User]
01 May 2022 07:34

Missed Deadline for Monthly Review at University of Birmingham

User: PhDinUK2022 - 01 May 2022 07:34

Hi Everyone,

I am having a little bit of a panic moment here. I am currently doing a PhD at the University of Birmingham, and I was unable to complete the GRS2 form for April last night and today it will not allow me to complete it. The GRS2 form is UoB's monthly review form to keep track of the PGR and the Supervisor's interaction and the PGR's progress. All I needed to do was the last step of accepting the supervisor's comment and I missed the deadline.

I am worried about how this will affect my PhD. I have asked them if I can still amend it but if I can not does anyone know what the repercussions are? Any help would be appreciated.

abababa

[Registered User]
06 May 2022 02:12

User: abababa - 06 May 2022 02:12

Hi,

It's interesting they have a formal monthly review system - this is unusual. Normally, PhD progress is evaluated internally on an annual basis.

A PhD is - to use the cliche - a PhD. It doesn't have grading; it doesn't track what happened along the way. It just is.

As a consequence, the only way internal reviews will impact it, is if the outcome is the University refuses to allow you to continue to study. It is not in the University's best interests to do this as they lose the fees and prospect of a completion; it's generally done on an ethical basis that there is no realistic prospect of you completing, and therefore it's wrong to allow you to continue.

I would think you can rest easy that unless your research itself is way off-track (as judged by your supervisory team), failing to file paperwork will not be a deal-breaker. Many students also worry about training-credit style systems, or other hurdles the Uni implements. Ultimately if you're doing good research and can complete, they will let you do so.

It is still preferable to file paperwork where you can, as admin-types will get pent up about it, but I've never seen someone fail a PhD on the basis of a missed monthly meeting or training exercise.

Post reply on Postgrad Forum | Sort latest to earliest | Back to topics